Tuesday, July 30, 2013

2. Is It Ever Okay to Spank a Child?

After hearing about two situations concerning whether spanking is acceptable, Andrea Nair, a psychotherapist and parenting educator, writes an article questioning if there is any moment in which corporal punishment would be appropriate. A woman asked her whether she should have spanked her kid in hope that he would have become a better person. In addition, Nair tells that former NBA all-star, Michael Richardson, says the spanking he got from his mother kept him from committing mistakes. Contrary to the latter’s benefits from spanking, the author describes harmful consequences that it can cause in a child and mentions the bad view spanking has worldwide. Nair thinks that it is never appropriate to spank, but she does admit that sometimes situations like the woman’s and Richardson’s occur. Nair believes that spanking could stop if only alternatives to disciplining are used.


Nair fills her article with information, personal experience, and personal opinion. Being a psychotherapist and parenting educator, she includes a lot of personal experience she had with other people and her personal opinions concerning this topic. Nair explains how a lot of her personal experience caused her to question whether spanking is acceptable. Information regarding the negative side of corporal punishment is used to support her opinion. Although, despite the two situations she mentions have importance, some details Nair gives seem quite unnecessary.

No comments:

Post a Comment