Garance Franke-Ruta,
senior editor at The Atlantic, writes
about the statistical increase of poverty among single women over age 65 from
2011 to 2012. This phenomenon was unexpected since the percentage of poor elderly
women was stable for over a decade and it suddenly increased in one year. The reasons
are unsure, but a possible explanation is that reductions in Social Security
Administration funding might have directly affected those dependent on it. Franke-Ruta
says that as Baby Boomers age, overall poverty rates among the elderly will
increase. Also, because the overall poverty rate among elderly woman actually
decreased in the past decade, the increase of extreme poverty rate in the past
year was shocking.
Franke-Ruta
does an excellent job in her writing, but surprisingly commits some mistakes
that are not expected from a senior editor of a news website. The author uses
humor at the start by saying that “community colleges may need to start
teaching courses for women on "How to Be Old," because America 's
ladies are not doing a great job of figuring it out.” She uses the humor
effectively as an attention getter for her essay. Also, Franke-Ruta does add
some credibility to her ideas by including actual census statistics. She does remember
to cite the National Women's Law
Center , especially the
senior policy analyst, Katherine Gallagher Robbins, for all the information she
utilizes in her writing. To conclude her essay, the author adds "Will this
be a trend or a blip?" The reflective and rhetorical nature of this question
by Katherine Gallagher Robbins is a great way to end Franke-Ruta’s essay. Along
the essay however, Franke-Ruta seems to have made some obvious grammatical
mistakes. Some might have been done on purpose due to a specific writing style,
but others are confusing to the reader and don’t seem to have any intended use.
It is not certain if the author did those accidentally.
No comments:
Post a Comment