James
Hamblin, The Atlantic 's
Health editor, writes about advices given to Jewish people about preparing
oneself for fasting day, Yom Kippur. The author mentions that The Jewish Times does not recommend
overeating at the night before so the body doesn’t need more water and energy
to break down the excess food, but recommends complex carbohydrates that retain
energy and water. Hamblin suggests that one should tackle fasting as if it were
a marathon, using the same kind of tips. He then points out NPR’s suggestion of
having kreplach, the equivalent of a Jewish wonton, to sustain. Hamblin finally
ends with a comment about fasting being bad for the body, but possibly good for
the soul. His own suggestion is that one should fast, but also not go beyond the
body’s limits by being aware of one’s own health.
The author does
an effective job in this essay. He uses an informal tone with the audience,
which does a good job of creating a connection with the reader. The writing is
easy to understand because it has the appearance of a conversation. This is
evidenced by the usage of pronouns like “you” and “I”. Hamblin also cites his
sources from where he gets different advices, which is important for the effectiveness
of his reliability. He does an excellent job in doing this, except for the
advice that was given by Derek Thompson. This one is not so reliable, because
he is mentioned to be simply one of Hamblin’s colleagues, not an important
newspaper or national radio organization, such as The Jewish Times and NPR. What is just as significant is the usage
of background information concerning the fasting day and Jewish culture. This
is very useful so other readers who are not familiar with the culture can understand
what is being discussed.
http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2013/09/how-to-fast-in-comfort/279667/
Well-written analysis! Could include some more rhetorical devices, and a few small grammar mistakes here and there concerning pronouns
ReplyDelete